The global commodity market is characterized by cycles of low and stable prices that are frequently interrupted by sharp price spikes. These booms are often followed by periods of high and more volatile prices. A key question for economists and market participants is whether the current high prices of commodities will last, and if so, for how long. Understanding the forces behind these fluctuations is essential for policymakers, producers, and consumers.

Christophe Gouel, senior research fellow at the National Research Institute for Agriculture, Food and the Environment in France and Nicolas Legrand, research assistant professor in the Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, tackled this issue.

Historically, economists have used the rational expectations storage model to explain the behavior of commodity prices. In this model, the concept of storage plays a central role in determining price persistence. When commodities are stored, prices tend to remain low or stable. On the other hand, when inventories are low or depleted, prices can become volatile and rise sharply. Speculators, who buy low and sell high, also contribute to price fluctuations by linking current prices to expected future prices, creating patterns of autocorrelation (a situation where current prices are related to past prices).

While this model offers a useful framework, it has faced challenges in explaining the observed persistence of prices in the real world.

Despite the model's shortcomings, research addressed these issues by introducing more complex model extensions. For example, some studies added elements like supply responses, demand shocks, and the role of trends in prices and quantities. However, these approaches still face limitations in how well they could explain price dynamics, especially in real-world markets where shifts in supply and demand are constant and unpredictable.

Legrand and Gouel’s research present a solution to these issues by developing a more advanced storage model. This new model incorporates dynamic features that better capture the interactions between supply, demand, storage, and prices. To achieve this, the research introduces an empirical methodology that combines theoretical modeling with real-world data to provide a more accurate picture of how prices and quantities are connected by storage decisions.

The New Approach: A Three-Step Solution

The proposed research follows a three-step process:

  1. Develop a New Storage Model: The first step involves creating a more dynamic storage model that incorporates features like supply responses, long-term trends, persistent demand shocks, and multiple types of supply shocks. This richer model is designed to better reflect the complexities of real-world markets.
  2. Empirical Methodology: The second step introduces an empirical methodology based on indirect inference. This method allows researchers to estimate the structural parameters of the storage model by analyzing the joint dynamics of price and quantity data. This is a crucial advancement because previous models often relied only on price data, which limited their ability to capture the full range of market dynamics.
  3. Apply the Model to Real Data: The third step involves applying the model to a comprehensive dataset of global grains market data, which includes time series on prices, production, consumption, and yield shocks. This empirical application shows that the new model can better capture the persistence of commodity prices, especially in the food market, which is a key area for economic stability.

Key Findings from Research

The research reveals several important insights:

  • Autocorrelation Puzzle Solved: By fully specifying the storage model, the study shows that about 40 percent of the observed one-year autocorrelation in prices can be explained by storage decisions. Other factors, such as price trends, demand shocks, and supply shocks, also contribute to price patterns.
  • The Role of Demand Shocks: While supply shocks are important, the study finds that large positive demand shocks—such as sudden increases in consumer demand—are primarily responsible for the dramatic price spikes seen over the past six decades. This highlights the critical role of storage in buffering against such shocks.
  • Impact of Storage: The model demonstrates that storage not only helps smooth out supply disruptions but also plays a role in preventing prices from collapsing when inventories are high. The ability to store commodities allows speculators to bridge the gap between supply and demand, ensuring that price fluctuations do not become too extreme.

The insights gained from this research have important policy implications, especially for understanding the sources of commodity price volatility and how best to manage it. For instance, understanding the role of storage in stabilizing prices could guide policies aimed at improving storage infrastructure or influencing market speculation. Additionally, the model can help policymakers assess the impact of demand shocks, such as those caused by shifts in global consumption patterns, and how these can lead to price spikes.

This study offers a comprehensive approach to understanding the dynamics of global commodity prices by improving on traditional models of price persistence and volatility. By incorporating a richer storage model and applying advanced empirical techniques, the research provides a clearer picture of how supply and demand shocks, along with storage decisions, drive price fluctuations.

While the focus of the study is on the grains market, the methodology developed can be applied to other storable commodities like oil, offering a more robust framework for analyzing global commodity price dynamics.

Contact: